Can You File a Personal Injury Claim and a Workers’ Comp Claim at the Same Time?
Getting hurt at work doesn’t automatically limit you to workers’ compensation alone, when someone outside your employer is responsible.
By Michael Tamou · Updated August 14, 2026
Can You Pursue Both Workers’ Comp and a Separate Injury Claim?
Quick answer: Yes, in certain circumstances. Workers’ compensation is generally the exclusive remedy against your own employer, but if a third party, a negligent driver, a defective product manufacturer, a different company’s employee, contributed to your work injury, you may be able to pursue a separate personal injury claim against that third party alongside your workers’ comp benefits.
On This Page
- Can You Pursue Both Workers’ Comp and a Separate Injury Claim?
- The Exclusive Remedy Rule
- When a Third-Party Claim Becomes Available
- Common Third-Party Scenarios
- How the Two Claims Interact
- Why a Third-Party Claim Can Recover More Than Workers’ Comp Alone
- Steps to Take if You Were Hurt at Work by Someone Other Than Your Employer
- FAQs
The Exclusive Remedy Rule
Arizona’s workers’ compensation system generally provides benefits to injured workers, medical treatment, wage replacement, and other benefits, in exchange for barring a separate negligence lawsuit against their own employer. This is often called the exclusive remedy rule, and it applies regardless of whether your employer was actually careless.
This trade-off exists to provide injured workers with faster, more certain compensation without needing to prove fault, but it also means you generally cannot sue your own employer directly for additional damages, even if their negligence clearly caused your injury.
Awards & Recognition
Founding Partners Michael Tamou and Simon Touma’s personal injury litigation work has been independently recognized, earned, never purchased.
When a Third-Party Claim Becomes Available
If someone other than your employer, a driver who hit you while making a work delivery, a manufacturer whose defective equipment caused your injury, a different company’s negligent employee on a shared job site, contributed to your injury, you may have a separate claim against them, outside the workers’ compensation system entirely.
This distinction, employer versus a genuinely separate third party, is the entire foundation of whether a third-party claim exists. The key question is always whose negligence actually caused the harm, and whether that party has any employment relationship with you.
Common Third-Party Scenarios
Car accidents while driving for work (against the other driver, not your employer), injuries from defective tools or equipment (against the manufacturer), and injuries caused by another company’s employees or contractors on a multi-employer job site (against that other company) are common situations giving rise to third-party claims.
Construction sites are a particularly common setting for these claims, since multiple companies, a general contractor, various subcontractors, equipment suppliers, are often present, and negligence by any one of them, other than your direct employer, can support a separate claim.
How the Two Claims Interact
Workers’ compensation benefits and a third-party injury claim can generally both be pursued, though there are often coordination and reimbursement considerations, sometimes called subrogation, between the two that an attorney can help navigate. Your workers’ comp insurer may have a right to be reimbursed from any third-party recovery.
This coordination is a real, technical part of these cases, and getting it wrong can reduce your net recovery unnecessarily. An attorney experienced in both workers’ compensation and personal injury claims can structure a resolution that properly accounts for both.
Why a Third-Party Claim Can Recover More Than Workers’ Comp Alone
Workers’ compensation benefits are generally limited to medical costs and a portion of lost wages, they typically do not include compensation for pain and suffering. A separate third-party personal injury claim, by contrast, can include the full range of damages, including pain and suffering and other non-economic losses.
This is exactly why identifying a viable third-party claim matters so much for injured workers, it can mean the difference between partial and full compensation for what you actually lost.
Steps to Take if You Were Hurt at Work by Someone Other Than Your Employer
- Report the injury to your employer to start the workers’ compensation process.
- Identify everyone involved in causing the injury, not just your employer’s role.
- Preserve evidence related to any defective equipment, other drivers, or other companies’ negligence.
- Consult an attorney about a potential third-party claim before assuming workers’ comp is your only option.
Hurt at work by someone other than your employer in Arizona? Talk to our litigation team before you respond.
Call 602-932-6010Can You File a Personal Injury Claim and a Workers’ Comp Claim at the Same Time? FAQs
Can I sue my employer directly if I was hurt at work?
Generally no, workers’ compensation is typically the exclusive remedy against your own employer, with limited exceptions for specific circumstances.
What if a coworker’s negligence caused my injury?
This is usually still covered under workers’ compensation, since it involves your own employer’s workplace, though the specifics matter and should be reviewed with an attorney.
Does pursuing a third-party claim affect my workers’ comp benefits?
There can be coordination and reimbursement issues between the two, an attorney can help ensure this is handled correctly so you are not unnecessarily giving up value.
How do I know if a third party was involved in my work injury?
A thorough investigation into how the injury happened, who was involved, and what equipment or parties were present can reveal third-party involvement that is not always obvious right away.
Can I recover pain and suffering through workers’ compensation?
Generally no, workers’ compensation benefits typically do not include pain and suffering, which is one of the main reasons a viable third-party claim can be so valuable.
What if I was injured by defective equipment provided by my employer?
The equipment manufacturer, as a separate entity from your employer, may potentially be liable under product liability principles, this is worth investigating separately from your workers’ comp claim.
Do I have to choose between workers’ comp and a third-party claim?
No, in the right circumstances, both can be pursued together, with proper coordination between the two to maximize your actual recovery.
Key Takeaways
- Workers’ compensation is generally the exclusive remedy against your own employer.
- A separate claim against a negligent third party may still be available.
- Work-related car accidents and defective equipment are common third-party scenarios.
- The two types of claims can often be pursued together with proper coordination.
- A third-party claim can recover pain and suffering, which workers’ comp alone generally does not cover.
Visit Us
